Faults on Power System
Faults Calculations
Fault is any abnormal connection or situation in an electrical power system that causes voltage and current imbalance among the three phases.
1. Symmetrical Components
- Fortescue Theorem: any unbalanced 3-phase vector set breaks into 3 balanced vector sets
- Sequence Sets: positive sequence, negative sequence, and zero sequence components
- Symmetrical Analysis: decouples unbalanced system equations into independent sequence networks
2. Positive Sequence Components
- Definition: 3 equal vectors displaced by \(120^\circ\) having original \(a-b-c\) phase sequence
- Subscript Convention: denoted by subscript 1 (\(V_{a1}\), \(V_{b1}\), \(V_{c1}\))
- Operator Relations: \(V_{b1}\) lags \(V_{a1}\) by \(120^\circ\), \(V_{c1}\) leads \(V_{a1}\) by \(120^\circ\)
Positive Sequence Vector Relations
Where: \(V_{a1}, V_{b1}, V_{c1}\) = positive sequence phase voltages (V), \(a = 1\angle 120^\circ\) = complex vector operator, \(a^2 = 1\angle 240^\circ = 1\angle -120^\circ\)
3. Negative Sequence Components
- Definition: 3 equal vectors displaced by \(120^\circ\) having reversed \(a-c-b\) phase sequence
- Subscript Convention: denoted by subscript 2 (\(V_{a2}\), \(V_{b2}\), \(V_{c2}\))
- Operator Relations: \(V_{b2}\) leads \(V_{a2}\) by \(120^\circ\), \(V_{c2}\) lags \(V_{a2}\) by \(120^\circ\)
Negative Sequence Vector Relations
Where: \(V_{a2}, V_{b2}, V_{c2}\) = negative sequence phase voltages (V), \(a = 1\angle 120^\circ\) = complex vector operator, \(a^2 = 1\angle 240^\circ\)
EE Board Exam March 1998
Example. The three-phase unbalanced currents are \(I_a = 10\angle -30^\circ\ \text{A}\), \(I_b = 0\), \(I_c = 10\angle 150^\circ\ \text{A}\). Find the negative sequence current of phase a.
Solution.
Answer: \(5.77\angle -60^\circ\ \text{A}\)
4. Zero Sequence Components
- Definition: 3 equal vectors equal in magnitude and in phase with each other
- Subscript Convention: denoted by subscript 0 (\(V_{a0}\), \(V_{b0}\), \(V_{c0}\))
- Ground Path: zero sequence current requires a neutral or ground return connection
Zero Sequence Vector Relations
Where: \(V_{a0}, V_{b0}, V_{c0}\) = zero sequence phase voltages (V)
EE Board Exam October 1998
Example. The three-phase unbalanced currents are \(I_a = 10\angle -30^\circ\ \text{A}\), \(I_b = 0\), \(I_c = 10\angle 150^\circ\ \text{A}\). Find the zero sequence current.
Solution.
Answer: \(0\ \text{A}\)
5. General Formulas on Symmetrical Components
- Vector Operator \(a\): rotates a phasor counterclockwise by \(120^\circ\)
- Zero Vector Sum: \(1 + a + a^2 = 0\)
- Synthesis Equations: reconstruct original phase quantities from sequence components
Complex Operator \(a\) Identities
Sequence Component Transformation Formulas
Where: \(V_{a0}, V_{a1}, V_{a2}\) = zero, positive, and negative sequence components of phase a (V), \(V_a, V_b, V_c\) = unbalanced phase voltages (V)
Phase Synthesis Formulas
Where: \(V_a, V_b, V_c\) = synthesized phase voltages (V), \(V_{a0}, V_{a1}, V_{a2}\) = sequence components of phase a (V)
Example. Given three unbalanced three-phase voltages \(V_a = 150 + j0\ \text{V}\), \(V_b = -90 - j120\ \text{V}\), \(V_c = -120 + j90\ \text{V}\). Determine \(V_{a1}\).
Solution.
Answer: \(145.62 + j13.66\ \text{V}\)
6. Per Unit Impedance Using a Different Power and Voltage Base
- Per Unit Definition: ratio of actual quantity to chosen base quantity
- Base Change: converts per-unit impedance to a new MVA or kV base
Per Unit Impedance Base Conversion
Where: \(Z_{\text{pu1}}, Z_{\text{pu2}}\) = original and new per-unit impedances, \(V_{\text{base1}}, V_{\text{base2}}\) = original and new voltage bases (kV), \(S_{\text{base1}}, S_{\text{base2}}\) = original and new apparent power bases (kVA or MVA), \(Z_{\Omega}\) = actual impedance (\(\Omega\))
Example. A per-unit impedance \(Z_{\text{pu1}} = 0.03\ \text{pu}\) based on \(34.5\ \text{kV}\) and \(50\ \text{MVA}\). Convert to a new base of \(33\ \text{kV}\) and \(100\ \text{MVA}\).
Solution.
Answer: \(5.49\%\)
7. Sequence Networks: Zero, Positive, Negative
- Sequence Network: per-phase equivalent circuit corresponding to one sequence set
- Voltage Source Location: internal generated emfs (\(E_a\)) exist in positive sequence network only
- Passive Networks: negative and zero sequence networks contain no internal source voltages
Sequence Network Voltage Equations
Where: \(V_{a1}, V_{a2}, V_{a0}\) = sequence terminal voltages of phase a (pu or V), \(E_a\) = pre-fault open-circuit phase a voltage (pu or V), \(I_{a1}, I_{a2}, I_{a0}\) = sequence currents of phase a (pu or A), \(Z_1, Z_2, Z_0\) = positive, negative, and zero sequence Thevenin impedances (pu or \(\Omega\))
8. Single Line to Ground Fault
- Series Connection: positive, negative, and zero sequence networks connected in series
- Equal Sequence Currents: \(I_{a1} = I_{a2} = I_{a0}\)
- Total Fault Current: sum of three sequence currents (\(I_f = 3 I_{a0}\))
Single Line to Ground (SLG) Fault Equations
Where: \(I_{a1}, I_{a2}, I_{a0}\) = sequence currents of phase a (pu or A), \(E_a\) = pre-fault phase voltage (pu or V), \(Z_1, Z_2, Z_0\) = sequence impedances (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(Z_f\) = fault impedance (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(I_f\) = total line-to-ground fault current (pu or A)
EE Board Exam October 1998
Example. At a certain point of the system network the positive, negative and zero sequence impedances are \(0.25\ \text{pu}\), \(0.25\ \text{pu}\) and \(0.30\ \text{pu}\) respectively. The base MVA is \(100\). The voltage level at that point is \(34.5\ \text{kV}\). Determine the zero sequence current for a single line to ground fault.
Solution.
Answer: \(2091.81\ \text{A}\)
9. Line to Line Fault
- Parallel Connection: positive and negative sequence networks connected in parallel
- Zero Sequence Current: zero sequence current is identically zero (\(I_{a0} = 0\))
- Fault Current Relation: fault line current equals \(\sqrt{3} I_{a1}\)
Line to Line (LL) Fault Equations
Where: \(I_{a1}, I_{a2}, I_{a0}\) = sequence currents of phase a (pu or A), \(E_a\) = pre-fault phase voltage (pu or V), \(Z_1, Z_2\) = positive and negative sequence impedances (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(Z_f\) = fault impedance (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(I_b, I_c\) = line fault currents in phases b and c (pu or A)
Example. A \(20\ \text{MVA}\), \(13.8\ \text{kV}\), \(60\ \text{Hz}\), three-phase synchronous turbo alternator has positive, negative and zero sequence reactances of \(0.25\), \(0.35\) and \(0.15\) respectively. If lines b and c are short-circuited, determine the subtransient fault current in line b.
Solution.
Answer: \(2415\ \text{A}\)
10. Double Line to Ground Fault
- Parallel Branching: positive, negative, and zero sequence networks connected in parallel
- Ground Return Current: neutral/ground current equals \(I_n = I_b + I_c = 3 I_{a0}\)
Double Line to Ground (2LG) Fault Equations
Where: \(I_{a1}, I_{a2}, I_{a0}\) = sequence currents (pu or A), \(E_a\) = pre-fault voltage (pu or V), \(Z_1, Z_2, Z_0\) = sequence impedances (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(Z_f\) = fault impedance (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(Z_g\) = neutral-to-ground impedance (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(I_n\) = total current to ground (pu or A)
Example. In a short circuit analysis, the positive, negative and zero sequence impedances are \(0.20\ \text{pu}\), \(0.20\ \text{pu}\) and \(0.25\ \text{pu}\) respectively, using a base MVA of \(50\). Estimate the fault current on the faulted lines if a double line to ground fault at the \(138\ \text{kV}\) level occurs.
Solution.
Answer: \(1011\ \text{A}\)
11. Three-Phase Fault
- Symmetrical Fault: all 3 phases shorted together with equal fault currents
- Positive Sequence Only: \(I_{a2} = 0\) and \(I_{a0} = 0\)
- Most Severe Fault: generally yields maximum short-circuit MVA and current
Three-Phase (\(3\phi\)) Symmetrical Fault Equations
Where: \(I_{a1}\) = positive sequence fault current (pu or A), \(E_a\) = pre-fault phase voltage (pu or V), \(Z_1\) = positive sequence impedance (pu or \(\Omega\)), \(Z_f\) = fault impedance (pu or \(\Omega\))
EE Board Exam March 1998
Example. In a short circuit study, the positive, negative and zero sequence impedances are \(0.25\ \text{pu}\), \(0.25\ \text{pu}\) and \(0.3\ \text{pu}\) respectively. The base MVA is \(100\). Determine the fault current for a three-phase fault at the \(115\ \text{kV}\) level.
Solution.
Answer: \(2000\ \text{A}\)
11.1 kV-Base Method
- Ohmic Calculations: convert all network impedances to ohms on a common kV base
- Ohm’s Law Application: fault current calculated directly using \(I_f = V_f / Z_{\text{total}}\)
kV-Base Method Equations
Where: \(Z_c\) = impedance on common kV base (\(\Omega\)), \(Z_a\) = actual impedance (\(\Omega\)), \(V_c\) = common kV base (kV), \(V_a\) = original voltage base (kV), \(Z_{\text{total}}\) = equivalent network impedance (\(\Omega\)), \(V_f\) = phase voltage at fault point (V), \(I_f\) = fault current (A)
EE Board Exam March 1998
Example. A \(5\ \text{MVA}\), \(13.8\ \text{kV}/480\ \text{V}\), \(5\%\) impedance transformer is tapped at \(13.8\ \text{kV}\) line where the Thevenin’s equivalent impedance is \(1/2\ \Omega\). Determine the fault current at the primary for a three-phase fault at the secondary.
Solution.
Answer: \(3300\ \text{A}\)
11.2 kVA-Base Method
- Per Unit Conversion: convert all per-unit impedances to a common kVA/MVA base
- Short Circuit MVA: calculate fault power \(\text{kVA}_f\) and fault current \(I_f\)
kVA-Base Method Equations
Where: \(Z_{c\text{pu}}\) = per-unit impedance on common kVA base, \(Z_{a\text{pu}}\) = original per-unit impedance, \(\text{kVA}_c\) = chosen common kVA base, \(\text{kVA}_a\) = original kVA rating, \(\text{kVA}_f\) = short-circuit fault MVA/kVA, \(V_f\) = line-to-line voltage at fault point (kV), \(I_f\) = total fault current (A)
EE Board Exam March 1998
Example. At a certain location in an electric system, the available fault MVA is \(400\ \text{MVA}\). A \(15\ \text{MVA}\), \(34.5\ \text{kV}/6.24\ \text{kV}\), \(2.5\%\) impedance, wye-wye grounded transformer is installed at that location. Determine the short circuit MVA at the secondary side of the transformer.
Solution.
Answer: \(240\ \text{MVA}\)
12. Equivalence of Line to Line Fault and Three-Phase Fault on Unloaded Generator
- Unloaded Generator Property: positive sequence reactance equals negative sequence reactance (\(Z_1 = Z_2\))
- Current Ratio Factor: line-to-line fault current equals \(\sqrt{3}/2\) (or \(86.6\%\)) of 3-phase fault current
Line-to-Line and Three-Phase Fault Equivalence
Where: \(I_{LL}\) = line current during line-to-line fault (A), \(I_{3\phi}\) = line current during 3-phase fault (A)
EE Board Exam October 1982
Example. The reactance of a three-phase alternator is \(8\%\). If the alternator is rated \(25\ \text{MVA}\) at \(13.25\ \text{kV}\) output voltage, line to phase, solve for the magnitude of the fault current generated when a short circuit occurs between 2 phases at the terminals.
Solution.
Answer: \(6808\ \text{A}\)
13. Formula Summary
| Formula Name | Formula | Variables |
|---|---|---|
| Positive Sequence Vector \(V_{b1}\) | \(V_{b1} = a^2 V_{a1}\) | \(V_{b1}, V_{a1}\) = positive sequence voltages (V) \(a = 1\angle 120^\circ\) |
| Negative Sequence Vector \(V_{b2}\) | \(V_{b2} = a V_{a2}\) | \(V_{b2}, V_{a2}\) = negative sequence voltages (V) \(a = 1\angle 120^\circ\) |
| Zero Sequence Identity | \(V_{a0} = V_{b0} = V_{c0}\) | \(V_{a0}, V_{b0}, V_{c0}\) = zero sequence voltages (V) |
| Zero Sequence Voltage Component | \(V_{a0} = \dfrac{1}{3}(V_a + V_b + V_c)\) | \(V_{a0}\) = zero sequence voltage (V) \(V_a, V_b, V_c\) = phase voltages (V) |
| Positive Sequence Voltage Component | \(V_{a1} = \dfrac{1}{3}(V_a + a V_b + a^2 V_c)\) | \(V_{a1}\) = positive sequence voltage (V) \(V_a, V_b, V_c\) = phase voltages (V) |
| Negative Sequence Voltage Component | \(V_{a2} = \dfrac{1}{3}(V_a + a^2 V_b + a V_c)\) | \(V_{a2}\) = negative sequence voltage (V) \(V_a, V_b, V_c\) = phase voltages (V) |
| Phase Voltage Synthesis \(V_a\) | \(V_a = V_{a0} + V_{a1} + V_{a2}\) | \(V_a\) = phase a voltage (V) \(V_{a0}, V_{a1}, V_{a2}\) = sequence components (V) |
| Per Unit Base Conversion | \(Z_{\text{pu2}} = Z_{\text{pu1}} \left(\dfrac{V_{\text{base1}}}{V_{\text{base2}}}\right)^2 \left(\dfrac{S_{\text{base2}}}{S_{\text{base1}}}\right)\) | \(Z_{\text{pu1}}, Z_{\text{pu2}}\) = per-unit impedances \(V_{\text{base}}\) = base voltage (kV) \(S_{\text{base}}\) = base power (MVA) |
| Positive Sequence Network Voltage | \(V_{a1} = E_a - I_{a1} Z_1\) | \(V_{a1}\) = sequence terminal voltage (pu) \(E_a\) = generated emf (pu) \(I_{a1}\) = current (pu) \(Z_1\) = impedance (pu) |
| SLG Fault Sequence Current | \(I_{a1} = I_{a2} = I_{a0} = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1 + Z_2 + Z_0 + 3Z_f}\) | \(I_{a1}, I_{a2}, I_{a0}\) = sequence currents (pu) \(E_a\) = pre-fault voltage (pu) \(Z_1, Z_2, Z_0\) = sequence impedances (pu) \(Z_f\) = fault impedance (pu) |
| SLG Fault Line Current | \(I_f = 3 I_{a0}\) | \(I_f\) = total SLG fault current (A or pu) \(I_{a0}\) = zero sequence current (A or pu) |
| LL Fault Sequence Current | \(I_{a1} = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1 + Z_2 + Z_f}\) | \(I_{a1}\) = positive sequence current (pu) \(E_a\) = pre-fault voltage (pu) \(Z_1, Z_2\) = impedances (pu) \(Z_f\) = fault impedance (pu) |
| LL Fault Line Current | \(I_b = -j\sqrt{3} I_{a1}\) | \(I_b\) = fault line current in phase b (pu) \(I_{a1}\) = positive sequence current (pu) |
| 2LG Fault Sequence Current \(I_{a1}\) | \(I_{a1} = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1 + Z_f + \dfrac{(Z_2 + Z_f)(Z_0 + Z_f + 3Z_g)}{Z_2 + Z_0 + 2Z_f + 3Z_g}}\) | \(I_{a1}\) = positive sequence current (pu) \(E_a\) = pre-fault voltage (pu) \(Z_1, Z_2, Z_0\) = sequence impedances (pu) \(Z_f, Z_g\) = fault/ground impedances (pu) |
| 2LG Fault Ground Return Current | \(I_n = 3 I_{a0}\) | \(I_n\) = neutral/ground fault current (pu or A) \(I_{a0}\) = zero sequence current (pu or A) |
| Three-Phase Fault Sequence Current | \(I_{a1} = \dfrac{E_a}{Z_1 + Z_f}\) | \(I_{a1}\) = fault current (pu) \(E_a\) = pre-fault voltage (pu) \(Z_1\) = positive sequence impedance (pu) \(Z_f\) = fault impedance (pu) |
| kV-Base Impedance Conversion | \(Z_c = Z_a \left(\dfrac{V_c}{V_a}\right)^2\) | \(Z_c\) = converted impedance (\(\Omega\)) \(Z_a\) = actual impedance (\(\Omega\)) \(V_c, V_a\) = common and original kV bases |
| kVA-Base Impedance Conversion | \(Z_{c\text{pu}} = Z_{a\text{pu}} \left(\dfrac{\text{kVA}_c}{\text{kVA}_a}\right)\) | \(Z_{c\text{pu}}\) = converted per-unit impedance \(Z_{a\text{pu}}\) = original per-unit impedance \(\text{kVA}_c, \text{kVA}_a\) = kVA bases |
| Short Circuit Fault MVA | \(\text{kVA}_f = \dfrac{\text{kVA}_c}{Z_{\text{total,pu}}}\) | \(\text{kVA}_f\) = fault MVA/kVA \(\text{kVA}_c\) = base kVA \(Z_{\text{total,pu}}\) = total per-unit impedance |
| Line-to-Line Fault Equivalence Ratio | \(I_{LL} = \dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2} I_{3\phi}\) | \(I_{LL}\) = line-to-line fault current (A) \(I_{3\phi}\) = 3-phase fault current (A) |
